Reading Order
Dirty HandsLes Mains sales Reading Order
Les Mains sales (Dirty Hands, 1948) by Jean-Paul Sartre is a political thriller in the form of a play: Hugo, a young bourgeois idealist who has joined a Communist party in an unnamed Eastern European country, has been sent to assassinate Hoederer, the party's pragmatic leader, who is planning a compromise coalition with rival factions that the party's dogmatists consider a betrayal. When Hugo lives in Hoederer's house as his secretary, he comes to admire and even love the man he is supposed to kill; the assassination, when it finally happens, is triggered not by political conviction but by a moment of sexual jealousy. The play is structured around Hugo's retrospective attempt to make sense of what he did and why — and the central question is whether a political act can be meaningful if it is motivated by private feeling rather than ideological purity. Les Mains sales was received by the French Communist Party as an anti-Communist play and was immediately used by anti-Communist movements in Europe, which Sartre did not intend; he withdrew permission for productions in countries where it was being used as propaganda. The play is ultimately about the existentialist problem of 'dirty hands': the question of whether it is possible to act politically without compromise, and whether a man who has committed a genuine crime can retroactively give it political meaning.
Where to start
Les Mains sales
Complete Dirty Hands Book List
- 1Buy
Les Mains sales
Jean-Paul Sartre·1948·Start here — the complete play; typically performed in two and a half to three hours. - 2Buy
Huis clos
Jean-Paul Sartre·1944·The companion play — shorter and more philosophical, the closed room rather than the political thriller. - 3Buy
Le Diable et le Bon Dieu
Jean-Paul Sartre·1951·The larger-scale companion: Goetz's question (can one act with pure motives?) is the same question Hugo faces. - 4Buy
L'Homme révolté
Albert Camus·1951·The essay that caused the Sartre-Camus break — Camus's critique of revolutionary violence is the intellectual background to Hugo's situation.
Dirty Hands — Frequently Asked Questions
Why is Les Mains sales called 'Dirty Hands'?
The title refers to an idea that runs through the whole play: the idea that effective political action requires compromising one's principles — that to change the world you have to engage with it, make alliances with people you distrust, and make decisions that will harm some people to help others. Hoederer, the pragmatic Communist leader, explicitly articulates this position: he accepts that his hands will be dirty because he believes that the alternative — maintaining ideological purity while achieving nothing — is a form of vanity dressed up as principle. Hugo, the young idealist, cannot accept dirty hands: he kills Hoederer partly because of jealousy, partly because he cannot reconcile Hoederer's compromises with his own romantic conception of revolutionary action. The play is ultimately ambiguous about who is right: Sartre dramatises both positions with equal force, and the party's final decision to rehabilitate Hoederer and liquidate Hugo suggests that the dirty-hands position wins, but the play's emotional weight lies with Hugo. The concept of dirty hands entered political philosophy as a standard term for the problem of whether just ends justify unjust means.
Monthly Newsletter
Never miss a big release
Get the most anticipated upcoming books delivered to your inbox once a month — no spam, no filler.
Monthly only. Unsubscribe anytime.
Book links are Amazon affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate, BookReleaseRadar earns from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.